Our PFAS strategy can draw on the lessons learned from asbestos
This article was originally published by Ground Engineering in June 2026.
The UKβs PFAS Plan, published in February 2026, sets out the governmentβs first coordinated longβterm strategy for dealing with PFAS. RSK Geosciences PFAS and Emerging Contaminant Technical Lead Richard Colin shares his thoughts on how we can tackle PFAS by drawing on our success with other widespread contaminants in soils.
PFAS chemicals, or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, are highly persistent, with some taking more than 1000 years to break down in the environment owing to the strong carbon-fluorine bonds. They are also highly toxic, bioaccumulative and mobile in the environment. While this is an area of ongoing research, exposure has been linked to a long list of potential health effects, including cancer, endocrine disruption, ulcerative colitis, decreased immunity, decreased fertility and foetal and child developmental issues.
PFAS were developed in the late 1930s and have been used to such an extent in industrial and consumer applications that these chemicals are now widely present in soils and groundwater. As the problem has been with us for decades, it will likewise take decades to fully solve. We can do this by implementing immediate, mid-term and long-term actions.
The immediate actions should follow our management of other contaminants; we must break our dependency on these substances. The same properties that make PFAS a problem β stability, resistance to heat and combined hydrophobic and hydrophilic properties β are also the reason they have been considered to be useful. Research indicates over 200 use cases for PFAS, which means that, despite our knowledge of the drawbacks of these substances, the direct pathways for PFAS contamination are still open, which include chemical manufacturing, the use of firefighting foams both in emergency situations and training, manufacturing and waste handling.
It is crucial that we learn from our experiences and do not swap one form of PFAS for another, or for equally problematic chemicals. As an example, firefighting foams have removed long-chain PFAS in the form of PFOS (perfluorooctane sulfonate) but replaced this with other compounds that could be of concern to human health and the environment and are the subject of ongoing research and assessment.
Where viable alternatives to PFAS chemicals in firefighting foams, lubricants, food packaging and chemical manufacture are not readily available, we must prioritise their development if we are to break the chain of dependency.
There is a move from regulatory bodies to support industryβs innovation to find alternatives, addressing the issue via regulatory action and reducing emissions to the environment, outlined by both the Environment Agency (EA) via its PFAS plan and by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) in a public consultation on a proposed universal ban on PFAS under the EU REACH regulation.
Once we have a clear pathway to end our PFAS use, land remediation can begin in earnest. PFAS often accumulate in surface soils; however, like other contaminants of concern, over time they can migrate through the soil profile into subsoil and groundwater. They can also degrade from long- to short-chain PFAS, so the chemistry subtly changes over time in the environment. Remediation for the medium-term should focus on known sites where PFAS were used or present, and generally, these sites are where the top layers of soil are most heavily contaminated. They include chemical factories that produced or used PFAS, fire training grounds and aircraft and military sites.
Removing PFAS from soil can be carried out in a number of ways. The traditional method is excavation, removal and disposal into landfill sites licensed for this purpose, or excavation and βwashingβ of the soil, which separates and recovers the PFAS from within soil particles where moderate to high concentrations of PFAS are present. This does produce wastewater, which also then needs to be treated. Other treatment options include bioremediation, chemical agents or activated carbon to lock the PFAS in the ground. PFAS in soil can be destroyed by thermal treatment or incineration at specially designated facilities, where material is heated to high temperatures to break down the fluorine bonds and physically destroy the chemical compound. These methods are not cheap and have significant technical challenges. Measures such as these are not sustainable for the majority of sites that may exceed environmental and health-based targets, as they can also be affected by historical diffuse contamination. Focusing first on the most heavily contaminated sites gives the best return for the amount of PFAS removed, and it also prevents these chemicals continuing to migrate into groundwater, surface water and subsoil. We have seen a number of heavily impacted sites recently undergoing regulatory intervention via Part 2A of the Environmental Protection Act, with legal cases for personal injury ongoing. This was even highlighted in a recent TV documentary.
Turning our attention to the longer-term, we have to tackle indirect pathways and diffuse sources of PFAS contamination. This is where PFAS is not actively being used but has accumulated through the years and is being added back to topsoil, either through agricultural practices, such as the use of sewage sludge, contaminated composts and soil improvers, or simply from irrigation and rainwater, which can also contain PFAS.
Toxicology studies suggest there are no safe concentrations of PFAS. In the UK we currently use the statutory environmental quality standards (EQS) for PFOS of 0.65 nanograms per litre (ng/L) for assessment for impacts to inland freshwater bodies. The EA has since set criteria to protect human health when eating fish at 0.015 ng/L of PFOS, and set a requirement that the combined effects of different PFAS chemicals must be considered. While not yet statutory, it does indicate the likely direction in which regulation will go regarding PFAS exposure and health.
For soil risk to human health, we adopt the interim Category 4 Screening Level (C4SL) values for four specific PFAS chemicals. These are screening thresholds used to help decide whether land contamination poses an unacceptable risk to human health.
The interim C4SLs range from 0.17 to 0.0013 mg/kg (170β1.3 Β΅g/kg) based on the anticipated land use and PFAS substance. The assessment process requires consideration of additive exposure from all four PFAS, and therefore soils at much lower concentrations could cumulatively still be identified as a potential health risk.
Internationally, much lower threshold values have been adopted.
The practicality of identifying PFOS in soil and water at these threshold limits requires due consideration. Typical limits of detection for specialist UK commercial laboratories are circa 1 ng/L for waters and 1 Β΅g/kg for soils. In addition, as identified in the C4SL interim report, average exposure to PFAS from sources other than soil already exceeds tolerable toxicological thresholds.
We know that what was formerly considered good quality topsoil on even greenfield development sites could exceed these levels due to the diffuse spreading of biosolids containing PFAS. The criteria are limited to four substances and there may also be health and environmental risks from PFAS substances that do not have any current screening values, such as 6:2 or PFBS.
PFAS remediation is likely to be unfeasible for most developments on the grounds of cost and sustainability. This is particularly pertinent to sites affected by diffuse sources where even background concentrations could be indicated to pose a risk to human health or the environment based on current threshold criteria.
Traditional approaches to site remediation would involve disposal of soils at landfill, adding huge costs to site redevelopment, carbon emissions associated with the transport of contaminated soils and extensive testing to verify whether residual concentrations are acceptable, while passing on future PFAS liability to the waste sector. These burdens are not consistent with the requirement for sustainability to be embedded in each stage of contamination risk assessment.
In my opinion, a shift to a more pragmatic and sustainable approach would be more useful, rather than a blanket approach of attempting to achieve the very low and stringent criteria given a widely diffuse source.
Remediation with the aim of improving soil condition could be more readily achievable than trying to achieve an absence of PFAS, while also protecting the environment and end-users at the site. This would balance the need to reduce the prevalence of PFAS to as low as practicable, with the environmental requirement to be sustainable by safely reusing as much material on-site as possible. At a time when we are trying to find ways to lower emissions and our environmental impact, meeting unachievable PFAS requirements threatens to derail progress made in achieving a circular economy.
This question will be asked beyond soils, too. Is it better to reuse a potential waste product that is relatively low-cost for farmers, such as biosolids (sewage sludge), rather than it go to landfill, or to use manufactured products that may contain other potential contaminants and are more expensive?
Given that scientists have discovered widespread traces of PFAS in our blood and tissue and impact in uninhabited parts of Antarctica, the question some people will ask is whether complete remediation of PFAS, in soil or elsewhere, is a reasonable demand on society.
With many studies still ongoing, we are constantly learning more about the toxicity and environmental effects of PFAS, just as we are with microplastics and other chemicals like those present in tyres, such as 6PPD and 6PPD-quinone (6PPD-q). Therefore the health risks posed by PFAS are likely to be of increasing concern to society.
Many of the decisions in the longer-term will be social and political, rather than scientific decisions, trading-off what is feasible to test for and remediate and what is sustainable from a social and economic point of view.
The governmentβs PFAS plan is similarly structured to address immediate, mid-term and long-term actions by understanding PFAS sources, tackling pathways and reducing exposure through expanded monitoring of PFAS in water, soil, air, waste streams and foodβcontact materials and targeted restrictions. It sets out a number of actions for the regulator to tackle, including identifying and reducing PFAS at source and tackling historical sources of contamination. As PFAS testing and remediation grows in scope and use, the costs are likely to reduce, and the concentrations of PFAS allowed in soil will be lowered accordingly. Combined with stopping PFAS at the source, this will lead to a slow improvement over a longer timescale. Emerging developments like the use of microorganisms to break down PFAS and the prevalence of other contaminants, such as microplastics, for which similar social and political decisions may be needed, may also come into play.
In that sense, how we deal with PFAS will not be dissimilar to how we have dealt with asbestos, a once-crucial building material phased out over many years, or with lead, which after decades of use in petrol, paint and more still contaminates soils in urban areas that may result in a baseline health risk that is considered from an economical and political basis broadly acceptable to society at large.
In my opinion, the legacy of PFAS in land development can be managed effectively and sustainably, but only if we manage to break our dependence on these chemicals first.
Richard is a principal geoenvironmental engineer and technical lead for emerging contaminants at RSK Geosciences. He has over 22 yearsβ experience working in the contaminated land sector. He has a particular focus in the field of PFAS and has worked on many projects involving its investigation and assessment. He is also a Chartered Geologist and Scientist with the Geological Society of London, is a Qualified Person under the Definition of Waste Code of Practice and is a member of the Society of Brownfield Risk Assessment and the British Geotechnical Association (BGA).
Featured business

RSK Geosciences
RSK Geosciences is the UKβs leading site investigation, contaminated land and geotechnical consultancy and has more than 25 years of experience. We help our clients to realise opportunities and manage the potential liabilities associated with the acquisition, ownership, operation, development and divestiture of land. We work for both the public and private sectors, including many of the UKβs leading property developers, major and local house builders, utility providers and main contractors, local authorities and other government organisations.