A mine of information: Q&A with Dr Tom Henman
Published on January 31, 2020Ahead of this yearโsโฏBrownfield Land Scotland 2020โฏconference, which is taking place on 5 February in Edinburgh, UK, Environment Analyst caught up with RSK geosciences Director Dr Tom Henman, who shared his thoughts on the risks from mine related CO2 emissions.
Q. Have there been many other incidents of mine related CO2 emissions causing issues in properties?
Apart from the Gorebridge case that is well known, RSKโs research and consultation with local authorities and the Coal Authority has revealed that there were 15 recorded or anecdotally reported incidents in Scotland involving mine gas since the 1950s. Of these, 12 involved hazards from carbon dioxide emissions and three were related to methane. We also identified additional incidents that have occurred across coalfields in the rest of the UK, including a cluster of incidents known to have occurred inโฏNorthumberland in the 1990s.
Q. Is the drive to insulate buildings more creating conditions which give rise to more CO2 in buildings?
We examined this issue in detail through extensive consultation with stakeholders and industry experts. It is true that older draughty buildings are less prone to gas build-up due to the inherent increase in air exchange rate. In newer buildings, due to improved airtightness standards, gases able to enter a property are more likely to be retained, however the ingress of gas itself will also be reduced. Improved airtightness is of course needed to meet energy efficiency requirements and ultimately our climate change commitments. However, Government research on the effectiveness of indoor ventilation measures (and thus the assumed air exchange rate) indicates that improvements are needed to meet current building standards and inform residents of the importance of ventilation in homes. Therefore, the best option is to prevent gas ingress to properties in the first place.
Q. Are modern construction techniques which donโt create a sub ground void adding to the problem?
A ventilated void does help to provide a good basic level of defence against ingress of ground gases as gas concentrations are reduced before entry into properties. We found this construction method is used less commonly in Scotland now, as Modern Methods of Construction are adopted and due to Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) access requirements. However, other subfloor ventilation options are available and covered in relevant British Standards. Our work identified the potential need for further research to test the long-term effectiveness of granular fill and perforated pipe, commonly used as a passive ventilation technique, in areas affected by mine gas emissions.
Q. Is the current risk assessment process adequate in calculating potential future risks and construction impacts?
Our study concluded that existing standards and guidance for assessment of ground gas risk are generally adequate. Compliance was identified as the key issue as such assessments can be poorly implemented or have insufficient scrutiny by regulators. Despite recent changes to standards and guidance placing a greater emphasis on developing a robust conceptual site model and the use of quantitative risk assessment methods for complex sites, there can be an over-reliance by assessors on gas monitoring of boreholes and use of simple empirical approaches, e.g. gas screening values.
We made a series of recommendations to improve compliance, including use and enforcement of model planning conditions and changes to Scottish Planning and Building Standards and associated technical guidance. We also felt that applying the National Quality Mark Scheme (NQMS) to gas risk assessments would be of benefit in improving quality since there is a mandatory requirement for all reports registered under the scheme to consider data gaps/ uncertainties in land contamination assessments and their implications.
We also recommended further research and preparation of supplementary technical guidance to improve understanding of specific factors associated with mine gas emissions, including gas sources, relevant pathways, changes over time and the effect of cumulative development.
Q. Is the current scope of the guidance for mitigation measures tight enough?
Stakeholder views differed over the points-based system within British Standard BS 8485. We found some evidence of the standard being applied incorrectly as a prescriptive approach by consultants but also examples of some seeking to exploit loopholes in the guidance rather than using it to assist in the risk mitigation process. However, many expressed the view that if the gas risk assessment has been undertaken appropriately based on a robust conceptual site model then suitable recommendations for mitigation measures and implementation will follow. Appropriate verification of the installation of gas protection measures remains a key concern for many, although progress in this area is being made through various initiatives, such the British Verification Council, to improve the quality of workmanship and oversight.
Q. Is one of the problems the co-ordination between different departments in local authorities – Planning, Building Standards and Environmental Health?
This can be a challenge particularly where there is a โsiloโ mentality but we found some excellent examples of good practice in some Scottish local authorities, which we felt could be adopted more widely. Planning staff are noted to be under increasing pressure to approve residential developments quickly, which can affect timescales for scrutiny of assessments. We also identified the need for additional funding requirements to enhance capabilities for local authorities to critically review ground gas assessments through training or the use of independent external specialist support.
Want to know more?โฏJoin Environment Analyst at the upcomingโฏ Brownfield Land Scotland 2020โฏconference on 5 February in Edinburgh, where Tom and Andrew Gunning,โฏRSK@Stirling Managing Director,โฏwill be going into detail about a project that RSK was appointedโฏby the Scottish Government to carry out a research project into the prevalence of CO2 from disused mineral mines and the resulting risk to residential buildings. Book your place at the conferenceโฏhere.
๐ณ๏ธโ๐ RSK is proud to stand alongside members and allies of the LGBTQ+ community.
๐ People deserve to be their authentic selves and love freely without fear.
You can read Graeme and Abigail's full stories next week in RSK insights. Keep an eye on our social media for more information.
#rskfamily #pride #pridemonth #loveislove #lgbtq
๐ธ #selfiesonsite ๐คณ
Ryan Dunderdale, Senior Surveyor at Central Alliance, providing technical support and on-site training to datum plate install teams down in Bristol.
Want to join our team? View our latest opportunities ๐ www.rskgroup.com/careers
#RSKgroup #behindthescenes #meettheteam #RSKfamily #RSKonsite #engineering #construction
๐ In the June edition of our #employeespotlight, we spoke with with Rosie Pearce at Stephenson Halliday and Carmen Snowdon at WRc Group to find out about their recent achievements ๐
๐ Congratulations to you both!
Click the link in our bio to find out more!
#rskfamily #employeeapprecitation #team #landscapeinstitute #instituteofwater #architecture
"If you donโt feel valued, represented and respected in your workplace, then inevitably your #wellbeing will suffer.โ
๐ In our latest edition of #ADayInTheLife, we spoke with Ellen Lapworth-Maisey, Wellbeing, #Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Manager at RSK โ a fascinating position that helps to create an inclusive and empowering #culture for all RSK staff.
Click the link in bio to learn more!
#RSKGroup #RSKfamily #diversity #inclusion #mentalhealth
๐ธ #selfiesonsite ๐คณ
Some pictures of the Envireau Water staff on site.
Want to join our team? View our latest opportunities ๐ www.rskgroup.com/careers
#RSKgroup #behindthescenes #meettheteam #RSKfamily #RSKonsite #waterindustry #construction
๐ถ ๐ฃ๐ฒ๐ฑ๐ผ๐บ๐ฒ๐๐ฒ๐ฟ ๐๐ต๐ฎ๐น๐น๐ฒ๐ป๐ด๐ฒ ๐ฎ๐ฌ๐ฎ๐ฎ ๐ฐ๐ผ๐ป๐ฐ๐น๐๐ฑ๐ฒ๐ ๐ฎ ๐๐๐ฐ๐ฐ๐ฒ๐๐
#RSKSteps came to an end on Tuesday 31 May after a month of stepping adventures.
๐๐ป ๐ป๐๐บ๐ฏ๐ฒ๐ฟ๐:
โ๏ธ1449 participants
โ๏ธ332,268,416 steps
โ๏ธยฃ1500 raised for our chosen charity, MIND!
Read more about this fantastic challenge in our bio!
#RSKGroup #RSKfamily #wellbeing #health #mentalhealth #walking
#RSKEvents
๐ Join Dirk Van Look and Chris Hughes on our webinar all about #PFAS โ perfluoroalkyl substances, which are both human-made and known to be harmful to humans.
๐ก We will showcase real-life examples to demonstrate how RSK is responding and developing capabilities to assess these emerging #contaminants.
Find out more and register now in our bio!
#RSKGroup #RSKfamily #PFAScontaminants #foreverchemicals #chemicals
๐ In light of #PrideMonth, we are sharing information about how to become a better ally. #Pride offers a sense of solidarity and a platform for expression.
Keep an eye out for our upcoming posts!
#RSKGroup #rskfamily #LGBT #LGBTQ+ #inclusion #diversity #LGBTally #Pride2022
๐ข RSK is pleased to announce it has further expanded its presence in Ireland by acquiring one of the most reputable tree care companies in the country.
๐ณ Dermot Casey Tree Care was founded in the 1970s by Managing Director Dermot Casey and is one of the most highly regarded tree surgery companies in Ireland, with more than 50 years of experience.
Find out more in our bio!
#RSKGroup #RSKfamily #treecare #landscape #treesurgery #landscaping #nature